Which DDoS vendors have the worst lock-in?

Arbor (NETSCOUT) uses proprietary signaling between Sightline and TMS that does not work with third-party mitigation. Nokia Deepfield integrates tightly with Nokia routers. Fortinet requires their Security Fabric ecosystem. Radware needs multiple Radware products for full protection. The pattern is consistent across most enterprise vendors: detection and mitigation are sold as separate products that only work together.

What does vendor-agnostic DDoS protection mean?

Vendor-agnostic means the DDoS tool works with any BGP speaker, any scrubbing provider, any notification platform, and any monitoring stack. You are not locked into a single vendor's ecosystem for detection, mitigation, alerting, or reporting. Flowtriq supports 8 BGP adapters, 6+ cloud scrubbing providers, and alert delivery through Slack, Discord, PagerDuty, OpsGenie, Telegram, SMS, email, Teams, and webhooks.

Can I use Flowtriq with my existing network equipment?

Yes. Flowtriq works with any BGP speaker through 8 adapters: ExaBGP, GoBGP, BIRD 2, FRR, Cloudflare, Radware, F5, and a generic webhook adapter. It does not require any specific router vendor, firewall vendor, or network architecture. The agent runs on your existing servers regardless of the underlying infrastructure.

Does Flowtriq have a REST API?

Yes. Flowtriq provides a REST API for programmatic access to detection data, node management, attack history, and configuration. Combined with webhook support for both alerting and mitigation actions, Flowtriq integrates with any external system that can make or receive HTTP calls.

The Lock-In Problem

Your DDoS vendor wants you to buy everything from them

Q: What is vendor lock-in in DDoS protection?

Vendor lock-in occurs when a DDoS product is designed to only work with the same vendor's other products. Detection appliances that only signal to the same vendor's mitigation appliances, management platforms that only manage the same vendor's hardware, and reporting tools that only ingest the same vendor's data formats. Switching vendors means replacing everything at once.

Detection that only signals to the same vendor's mitigation. Mitigation that only integrates with the same vendor's routers. Reporting that only shows the same vendor's data. The pattern is everywhere, and it costs you flexibility, leverage, and money.

Start Free Trial → ← All Problems

"Should be more open to third-party systems, in the sense of coordination between mitigation centers. It allows it, but between its own systems only." Traffic Management Engineer, PeerSpot

"Currently it supports only its own box." Network Security Analyst, Gartner Peer Insights

"Tight integration with the vendor's IP routers... this is the lock-in." Senior Network Architect, PeerSpot

"If you need full protection you need to add more services/devices." Security Operations Lead, G2

Can it talk to our BGP speaker? Only theirs. Do we use theirs? No. Great.

See the full comic

The pattern

How vendor lock-in works in DDoS

Each major DDoS vendor has built a closed ecosystem where the products only reach their full potential when paired with more products from the same vendor. This is not a bug. It is the business model.

Arbor: Sightline to TMS only

Arbor Sightline (detection) uses proprietary signaling to communicate with Arbor TMS (mitigation). If you want automated mitigation from Sightline's detection, you need Arbor's own TMS appliance. Third-party mitigation platforms do not receive Sightline's signaling natively. Detection and mitigation are separate purchases that only work together.

Nokia: router integration lock-in

Nokia Deepfield provides its deepest integration with Nokia service routers. The tight coupling between Deepfield's analytics and Nokia's routing platform means operators using other router vendors get a diminished experience. The deeper you integrate, the harder it becomes to consider alternative routers or detection platforms.

Fortinet: Security Fabric requirement

FortiDDoS works best inside Fortinet's Security Fabric, which means FortiGate firewalls, FortiAnalyzer for reporting, FortiManager for management, and FortiSIEM for correlation. Each product enhances the others, but the practical effect is that choosing FortiDDoS pulls your entire security stack toward Fortinet.

Radware: multi-product requirement

Radware's full DDoS story requires DefensePro (on-prem mitigation), Cloud DDoS Protection (cloud scrubbing), DefenseFlow (orchestration), and AppWall (application layer). Each solves part of the problem. Full coverage means buying most of them. They communicate through Radware's own protocols and management plane.

Why it matters

The real cost of closed ecosystems

Lock-in does not just affect your DDoS tooling. It shapes every purchasing decision around it. Once your detection platform only talks to one vendor's mitigation, you cannot shop around for scrubbing services. Once your mitigation only integrates with one vendor's routers, switching router vendors means replacing your DDoS stack too.

This removes your negotiating leverage. When renewal time comes, the vendor knows exactly how painful it would be for you to switch. The cost of migration is your de facto floor price, regardless of what competitors charge.

It also limits your architecture choices. Networks evolve. You might move from one cloud provider to another, add edge locations at a new colo, or adopt a different BGP daemon. Vendor-locked DDoS tools constrain those decisions because every infrastructure change has to be evaluated against "will our DDoS protection still work?"

How Flowtriq addresses this

Vendor-agnostic by design

Flowtriq does not care what routers you run, which cloud provider you use, or where your infrastructure lives. It works with your stack, not instead of it.

Any BGP speaker

FlowSpec and RTBH mitigation works through 8 BGP adapters. You are not locked into a specific router vendor or BGP daemon. If you switch from FRR to BIRD 2 next year, Flowtriq still works.

ExaBGP

GoBGP

BIRD 2

FRR

Cloudflare

Radware

Webhook

Any scrubbing provider

Cloud scrubbing integrations cover the providers most operators actually use. You are not forced to buy a proprietary scrubbing service from the same vendor that sold you detection.

Cloudflare Magic Transit

OVH

Hetzner

DigitalOcean

Vultr

Linode

Any notification platform

Alerts go where your team actually looks. Not into a vendor-specific console that requires a separate login and VPN.

Slack

Discord

PagerDuty

OpsGenie

SMS

Teams

REST API and webhooks

Everything Flowtriq does is accessible through a REST API. Detection data, node management, attack history, and configuration. Webhooks provide real-time event delivery to any system that can accept HTTP POST requests. If you have a custom CMDB, runbook engine, or SIEM, Flowtriq fits into it rather than replacing it.

Where we're still improving

Adding more SIEM integrations, starting with Datadog and CloudWatch. If you need a specific integration today, the REST API and webhook adapter can bridge the gap.

Works with ExaBGP, BIRD, FRR, whatever. I did not have to rip out my whole stack.

See the full comic

Frequently asked questions

DDoS vendor lock-in: FAQ

What is vendor lock-in in DDoS protection?

Vendor lock-in happens when a DDoS product is designed to work only with the same vendor's other products. Detection that only signals to their mitigation, mitigation that only integrates with their routers, and management that only supports their devices. Switching any single component requires replacing the whole stack.

Can I use Flowtriq alongside my existing DDoS tools?

Yes. Flowtriq runs as a software agent on your servers and does not conflict with existing network-based DDoS tools. Some operators run Flowtriq alongside legacy appliances during migration. The REST API allows you to integrate Flowtriq data with your existing management and reporting platforms.

Does Flowtriq require specific router hardware?

No. Flowtriq works with any BGP speaker through 8 adapters. You do not need to change your routing infrastructure to use Flowtriq. The generic webhook adapter supports integration with any system that accepts HTTP calls, covering edge cases where a dedicated adapter does not exist yet.

What happens to my data if I stop using Flowtriq?

Your data is yours. Detection logs, attack history, and PCAP captures can be exported through the REST API at any time. There is no proprietary data format that locks your historical records inside the platform. If you leave, you take your data with you.

Is vendor-agnostic the same as open source?

No. Vendor-agnostic means the tool integrates with any infrastructure, regardless of vendor. Open source means the source code is publicly available. A tool can be vendor-agnostic without being open source. Flowtriq is a commercial SaaS product that integrates with any BGP speaker, scrubbing provider, and notification platform without requiring you to standardize on a single vendor's ecosystem.